Aird, Linval v R

Criminal appeal-Murder, Circumstantial evidence-Whether sufficient evidence for matter to be left to the jury-Whether judge erred in not upholding no case submission

Trial-Unfair Trial-Whether summation biased and unbalanced-Whether trial judge failed to adequately put self-defence before the jury-Whether the judge undermined the defence by descending in the arena and making unfair comments

Trial-Summing up-Whether judge adequately directed the jury on the forensic evidence-Whether judge adequately directed the jury on the circumstantial evidence and causation

Trial-Summing up-Good character direction-Whether good character direction diluted