Cleghorn, Andrew v R

Criminal Law-Evidence-Identification evidence-Identification by recognition-Inconsistencies and discrepancies-Discrepancy between eyewitness evidence and medical evidence-Whether trial judge gave adequate directions-Whether trial judge made unorthodox comments

Criminal Law-Evidence-Alibi-Comments by the trial judge-Whether judge's comment in alibi directions went beyond that which is permissible resulting in a reversal of the burden of proof

Criminal Law-Summing up-Unsworn statement from the dock-No good character direction given-Whether issue of good character was distinctly raised-Whether accused entitled to propensity limb of the good character direction