Old National Bank T/A Old National Weather Management (Personal Representative int he Estate of Raymond John Ryan) v Al Socrates Jobson, Michael Anthony Jobson and Demetri Anthony Jobson

(Considered on paper pursuant to rule 2.4(3) of the Court of Appeal Rules 2002)

Civil Procedure-Specific disclosure-Application for disclosure of documents bearing specimen signatures-Refusal of the application-Whether specimen signatures required for examination by handwriting expert are directly relevant to matters in issue in the proceedings-Whether specimen signatures necessary for fair disposal of the claim or to save costs-Whether order for specific disclosure should have been granted-Rule 28.1(4), 28.6(5) and 28.7 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2002